Monday, November 16, 2009

알 유 아 굿 다운로더?



A recent example of excessive "English" use in Korea, the "굿 다운로더" (Good Downloader) campaign.



Commercials featuring Korean actors are discouraging people from illegally downloading movies. There are a bunch available on Youtube, including:



Ah, I meant to write "discouraging people from illegally downloading Korean movies," because the Naver page, this "Good Downloader" page, and that commerical are referring to Korean ones.



The campaign isn't that new, but I've only started seeing the commercials on TV. From a Korea Times piece last month:
The anti-piracy campaign, ``I'm a Good Downloader,'' featuring top Korean stars garnered much interest Friday afternoon at the outdoor stage of the PIFF Village. Hallyu star Jang Dong-gun, who appears in the festival's opening film ``Good Morning President,'' and actresses Ha Ji-won and Uhm Jung-hwa, heroines of ``Haeundae,'' took part in the event.

"Haeundae recently suffered from piracy. This negatively affects our country as a whole, and I hope this can be an opportunity to change our downloading habits,'' said Ahn Sung-ki, veteran actor and director of the campaign.

This is Korea, and of course people will be concerned with protecting the local market. However, the hubbub over illegal copies of Korean movies online is especially ironic, considering South Korea is where copyright comes to die and is, dare I say, a "hub" of piracy. In September, as Chris in South Korea has written, the local entertainment industry was angry about illegal copies of the movie Haeundae available in China:
The Korean film industry is seething after a copy of the blockbuster "Haeundae" was found being illegally distributed over the internet last weekend, especially since the film had galvanized the industry by becoming the fifth Korean film ever to draw over 10 million viewers. Public calls for strong legal action against piracy are gaining support, but it might be too late to stop the spread of the bootleg overseas as it is already circulating on Chinese websites.

However, a trip to Seoul will show how easy it is to find bootleg copies of all the top movies, as you'll find vendors on busy intersections selling four for 10,000 won. Hell, at E-Mart last year I bought a copy of a Nintendo 64's "Mario Kart 64" ripped to a CD-ROM. Piracy is so rampant here that in 2008 both Warner Brothers and Sony have shut down DVD distribution in South Korea (though Warner Brothers has done what it needs to do to survive in this day and age). From the Korea Times last year:
Although Internet piracy is more of a concern, movie studios are frustrated about the private DVD copies sold on the streets. Street vendors camped in front of subway stations selling three to four private copies for a single 10,000 won bill are almost part of the landscape. In the film council’s survey, 8.1 percent of respondents said they have bought pirated DVD copies on the streets at least once.

This is to say nothing of piracy and "borrowing" of overseas music, pornography, software, designer brands, textbooks, and other intellectual property here. It's a little crass and hypocritical to worry about copyright infringement only when it concerns Korean products. People are taking the angle now that illegal downloading hurts Korea's film industry, but perhaps they could adjust that a little to hit on another common theme: __________ is bad for Korea's international image. Not simply because stealing makes Koreans look like, well, thieves, but because it discourages big companies (Sony, Warner Brothers, Nintendo) from bothering with the country at all.

6 comments:

kushibo said...

perhaps they could adjust that a little to hit on another common theme: __________ is bad for Korea's international image.

Sure illegal downloading could hurt Korea's international image, if it weren't a huge problem in just about every other country in East Asia, not to mention the rest of the world.

DSW said...

Haha, I use the phrase "Korea is where _____ comes to die" all the time in everyday speech. Weird. Great minds think alike. It's a particularly apt phrase when "copyright" fills the blank. I remember laughing when my kids told me about that "Good Downloader" shit.

Charles Montgomery said...

The problem is that the meme(?) Kushibo touches on...

perhaps they could adjust that a little to hit on another common theme: __________ is bad for Korea's international image.

could have its blank filled with myriad words while, if you turn it around?

perhaps they could adjust that a little to hit on another common theme: __________ is GOOD for Korea's international image.

the list is brutally short.

I agree that haters are gonna use that first model, but it is up to Korea, if it really gives a sh*t about globalization or whatever, to limit words that can fit in the first phrase, and proliferate words that can fit in the second.

• sutbul
• soju
• communality
• literature
• art
• friendliness (yah KRD, if you're friendly to Koreans they normally return it in multiples)
• farking brilliant products
• farking cheap not so brilliant products ;-)

the problem is Korea (LOL.. like it's one entity) hasn't done a good job at spreading the things that fill in the second blank.

Unknown said...

"Are you a good downloader?" (here's and idea; why not write a whole ad campaign in hangeulized English)

Quite frankly the illegal download business is even worse in Korea than it is in other countries. Sites like TPB and mininova etc don't make massive profits and only get a little from advertisements (probably enough to keep their websites running). However Korean illegal download sites often include things like paid subscriptions and download fees (on top of ads) for already illegal content thereby profiteering massively on illegal business. These sites would be simple to shut down and charge the accused as they've already provided their credit card numbers but the Korean Government doesn't give a shit about anything unless it affects themselves. Then again this is kind of similar to the self absorbed nature of Korean society anyway.

Mike said...

Kushibo,
A land of thieves does not detract from any single person's blame...

You'd hate to have people equating Korea with the likes of China when it comes to human rights, don't allow it to happen for copyrights either.

Powering Through said...

I guess the 2007 Korea-US FTA signed agreement on copyright did'nt do a thing although I believe that agreement caused some protests about some meat or something