Sunday, July 12, 2009

Boryeong "shrugs off" concerns about mud safety.


From Newsis.

Kang Shin-woo of the Korea Times is a little ambiguous here, as the headlines says "Boryeong Shrugs Off Mud Contamination," though the first paragraph says it's the "Thousands of holidaymakers" doing the shrugging. The article continues:

The regional health agency has yet to determine the exact cause of the skin inflammations suffered by about 230 children after participating in the pre-events between July 4 and 5.

Research is being conducted on samples of mud, water and other substances, with results expected as early as Tuesday.

``For now, we presume it’s because of some contaminated water coming from Daecheon Stream and an unhygienic environment downtown,’’ a festival organizer told The Korea Times Sunday.

The official insisted the mud itself was safe and the festival was going ahead on Daecheon Beach as scheduled. ``We are using cleaner water and strengthening all sanitary steps so tourists don’t have to worry about it.’’

Interesting to note that the news of the sick schoolchildren from a nearby "mud experience" in Boryeong wasn't reported anywhere in English except on this site, curious because thousands of foreigners attend the festival each year, are heavily represented in photographs and news coverage, and are prominently displayed on most of the promotional material. Last year 83,000 of the 2,266,000 people who attended during the festival's nine days were foreigners, making it, according to several sources, the Korean festival that attracts the most foreign visitors. It's more appropriate to write that festivalgoers "shrugged" rather than "shrugged off," because these concerns about mud safety weren't reprinted in the local English-language media.




The last three posters for the Boryeong Mud Festival, in reverse order.

One site is reporting the following:
Boryeong just south of Seoul, South Korea is the place where hundreds of people complained of itching on their skin and some had to go the hospital the skin discomfort they contracted in the pre-events of 'Boryeong Mud Festival'. According to city administration, some 200 participants contracted some kinds of skin inflammations while they were undergoing mud baths in the pre-Mud Festival events. The mud bath events were held on the embankment of Daecheon Stream in Daecheon-eup, Boryeong City, for two days.

. . .
The events were hosted by Boryeong City, the official host of the 'Boryong Mud Festival'.

The participants including many foreigners reportedly enjoyed mud bath, and mud slides and other mud-related facilities.

They are still being treated with various symptoms coming from dermatitis.

In one case some 50 students of a grade school are complaining of symptoms of dermatitis including itching.

And another site says:
According to the City Administration, around 200 out of 1,500 festival-goers were infected with some kinds of skin inflammations while they were undergoing mud baths in the pre-Mud Festival events.

The participants, including many foreigners, are still being treated with various symptoms coming from dermatitis.

The last line is of course ambiguous, because readers might get the impression that foreigners are among those being treated for dermatitis. Earlier in the article is says hundreds of people were hospitalized after they got sick at the festival, when in fact they developed rashes at another site in the city the week before the mud festival. Neither of those two pages cite any sources, and unless the two writers are based in South Korea, there's no reason to trust what they've compiled on their sites.

The festival will continue through next week, convenient for those kept away this weekend by the mud or the heavy rain. For what it's worth, the Boryeong Mud Festival is considered among the best festivals in the country. Google can tell you more, but for now here's what a Korean Tourism Organization profile has to say:
Out of all of the festivals in Korea, the Boryeong Mud Festival attracts the most international visitors every year. Last year it was recognized by the Ministry of Culture, Sports & Tourism as one of the best festivals in Korea. This year the festival will run for nine days (July 11th – July 19th) at Boryeong City’s Daecheon Beach in Chungcheongnam-do Province. Boryeong’s mud flats have a high concentration of Germanium and a host of other minerals that are beneficial for the skin. During the festival, many fun activities are organized such as mud slides, mud wrestling, and mud massages, enabling visitors to become covered from head-to-toe in this “healthy” mud. With festivities running day and night, the Boryeong Mud Party is a fun-packed beach party that’s sure to be a highlight of your summer. Every year, the festival is visited by around 80,000 international travelers. Make sure you don’t miss out!

Feel free to post first-hand accounts of your experiences this weekend, or browse the Naver news aggregator to see if your picture has turned up anywhere.

9 comments:

kushibo said...

Earlier in the article is says hundreds of people were hospitalized after they got sick at the festival, when in fact they developed rashes at another site in the city the week before the mud festival. Neither of those two pages cite any sources, and unless the two writers are based in South Korea, there's no reason to trust what they've compiled on their sites.

Two points. First, this type of reporting you mention (and there are lots like it) underscore that poorly written or researched articles are not limited to those about foreign residents in Korea.

Second, that last poster seems to highlight an Asian-looking (and probably Korean) female getting touchy and friendly with a Western-looking guy.

WORD VERIFICATION: dirtio

3gyupsal said...

Wow, I bet that no one expected to get that kind of dirty at the mud festival.

Anonymous said...

Any first hand accounts on this? im also skeptical about that news. Tracking the culprit in epidemiological cases is always tricky and not easy. Im going there this Saturday, and ill be happy to get some news updates prior to my travel.

JazzyAbby said...

I would just like to say that i knew about the risks of getting the rash before I went and now I am suffering... My friend and I have red bite like bumps all over our feet and legs.. At first I thought this was just bites but now i am sure it's the skin rash.. Anyways... I just wanted to say that we knew about the risks before we ever went to mud fest... other than the rain and the rash we had a great time.. FYI.. I won't be going next year.. this rash SUCKS!

Brian said...

Interesting, Abby, thanks for sharing. You should probably get it checked out. Who knows, though, it could be anything, from anywhere. I wonder if others will come forward, and if health authorities will attribute it to the mud.

Unknown said...

just giving you a heads up, this story has also been taken on-board by the Australian media
http://www.news.com.au/travel/story/0,28318,25772703-5014090,00.html

Brian said...

Thanks for that link. It's similar to what I pasted in the post. The article is just reiterating the news of the schoolchildren---who were NOT sick at the actual festival---and doesn't provide any sources or additional information about the sick foreigners.

Unknown said...

The guy on the 3rd poster (10th festival?) really reminds me of Bill Kapoun (the teacher who sadly passed away last year after a house fire).

Peter said...

I've never been to Mudfest because, as much fun as I'm sure it is, I don't like the way the event is used to perpetuate stereotypes. If "83,000 of the 2,266,000 people who attended during the festival's nine days were foreigners" last year, that means roughly 4% of the attendees were foreign, and yet the vast majority of published images from Mudfest are of foreigners. Just look at the promotional posters displayed here; of the three, only the third one prominently features even one person who might be Korean. The third poster is also the only one with more than a smattering of English text (in fact, the second poster, plastered with images of frollicking foreigners, features NO English text aside from the web address and "Korea Sparkling"). Rather than being aimed at foreigners, these posters are mainly designed to attract Koreans to the spectacle of a bunch of half-naked foreigners pretending they're on spring break. Maybe I'm taking this too seriously, but all I know is, there are plenty of things to do on the weekend in Korea that won't end up making us all look like jackasses.