Thursday, June 4, 2009

WSJ on Dunkin' Donuts in Korea.

Here's an excerpt from the Wall Street Journal today:
With their austere interiors, Dunkin' Donuts outlets in the U.S. cater to grab-and-go commuters seeking their morning caffeine fix. But in South Korea, breakfast is traditionally consumed at home and most customers are young women and teenagers who go for a snack in the afternoon or evening.

"I come to Dunkin' nearly every day after lunch to drink coffee," said Shin Min-hye, 25 years old, an office worker at a Seoul law firm who was sipping an iced coffee and eating cacao honey dip munchkins at a Dunkin' outlet. She was there studying English with a friend. "I like to hang out here because I can stay as long as I want to....I sometimes study here for hours."

Dunkin' stores in Korea encourage that kind of lingering with plush orange and yellow chairs, wi-fi Internet access and plasma-screen televisions. But Dunkin's recently named chief executive, Nigel Travis, said he wants to get Koreans into the habit of picking up doughnuts and bagels on their way to work in the morning. "The trick we need to focus on is how we build a breakfast business," he said.

The first challenge: creating a morning coffee habit in South Korea, where older generations favor tea. To do that, the company in April opened a coffee-roasting facility in Korea -- its first outside the U.S. -- so it no longer has to import coffee from America.

There are commercials all over TV for Dunkin' Donuts coffee with Lee Min-ho of "Boys Over Flowers," though until this morning I didn't understand that they were saying "Roasting." Regarding altering the coffee and snack culture of Korea, I can't say I like hearing executives talk about creating habits, anymore than I like spending 3,500 won for what the menu says is "coffee." Dunkin' Donuts is good for what it is, though, a clean, usually roomy place to sit, chat, and eat some donuts. I'd kind of like to see this style imported back home, rather than the other way around.

For a look at how McDonald's changed itself to meet the needs of its East Asian markets, or rather how Asian customers localized the McDonald's experience, take a look at this post from February, and the book Golden Arches East by James L. Watson. From a 2003 interview with the author (.pdf file), talking here about Hong Kong:
At first the local McDonald’s management tried to make the students eat faster and leave sooner, but they just sat there. Soon, however, management decided that this was an excellent development because it created the image of McDonald’s as a safe, and therefore family-friendly, institution: No alcohol, no smoking, noprofanity, and most important in a place like Hong Kong, no triad gangsters.

And a little from the book about the difficulty of convincing Korean customers that McDonald's was actually a meal:
Since its introduction in the ninteenth century, bread has never been incorporated into the standard meal system; instead it is perceived as a snack food. The Korean term for snack is kansik, literally "in-between food." Meat, on the other hand, has always been a highly valued, desirable food, and it is eaten almost exclusively at mealtime. To attract a steady flow of customers who would make substantial purchases, McDonald's had to represent itself as a place where one ate a full meal, as opposed to a snack bar where people spend little money but stay for hours chatting. To the dismay of local management, most Koreans considered McDonald's restaurants to be snack bars . . . To change this perception, the "value meal" was introduced[.]

I suspect Dunkin' Donuts and other Western chains have to do similar soul-searching.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

Very interesting post. Thanks, Brian.

WeikuBoy said...

There are two good coffee shops in my area, both of which do not even open until 10:30 (which I quickly learned really means 11). I think it's fair to say that Koreans see coffee as an afternoon pick-me-up or a date drink, rather than as a morning staple.

It's actually been much healthier for me to break the heavy daily coffee habit. Now I drink real coffee only once or twice a week, and enjoy it a whole lot more.

I know for a fact that Koreans like American breakfast foods (omelets, pancakes, waffles, etc.). Yet there are almost no breakfast or brunch-type places. (I'm not in Seoul.) I once described an American-style diner to a group of students, and was informed that Koreans would never go for that, as they are far too busy to sit down for breakfast in the morning.

Still, I think there is great potential for coffee and breakfast-related businesses here, though of course they will have to adapt to local culture, just like McDonalds and others have done in Asia. (Breakfast for dinner, anyone?) I wonder why chains such as IHOP and Denny's haven't tried their luck here (or have they?). I wonder the same thing about Chik-Fil-A, which I think would do very well here.

Brian said...

As much as I love me some IHOP, I know I probably wouldn't be pleased with the result were it in Korea. I mean, I've seen what pizza and coffee have become here, I'm sure they'd make pancakes with shrimp in it, or something.

I'm not in Seoul either, of course, and the only place where there's a Westernish breakfast option is McDonald's, which I think is now open 24 hours. I've never seen it busy in the morning, and even when I walked by the one in downtown Gwangju on Saturday morning it was dead. I'm curious to see how successful the McMorning menu has been, and whether it justifies being open so early.

I know from my days at McDonald's, in the morning before work was among the busiest times, and not simply because there were so few employees there. The labor percentage---that is, the percent of the incoming revenue that goes to pay hourly wages---was always quite low in the morning.

Something I'd like Western restaurants to do, rather than trying to create habits, is to better monitor the quality of service and product. Perhaps the responsibility is on us as consumers to report on poor service---or on great service and ideas (such as recycling cups and plastic) as the case may be----but it kills me when it takes ten minutes to get an order at McDonald's because there're only two people working in the evening, or when we pay $30 at Outback for a hockey puck, or when you order the "coffee of the day" at Starbucks (or whatever it's called now), and they serve you the stalest crap at the bottom. I know service can suck back home, too, but some of what goes on here is ridiculous.

Anyway, I don't mean to be so cranky, I like Dunkin' Donuts and a few of the other Westernish chains.

Stephen Beckett said...

Being British, I feel that I'm independent in this debate, and I'd like to say that you Americans should keep your breakfasts to yourselves. Anywhere where the people are staying away from McDonald's at breakfast time has got to doing something right. And as for Dunkin' Donuts - the very notion that anyone would want something so patently sugary and sickly as a doughnut for breakfast makes me need a sit down and a cup of Earl Grey.

WeikuBoy said...

No one has challenged me on this yet, but I certainly didn't mean to imply that I think Americans invented omelets (France?), pancakes (Holland?), and waffles (Belgium?), etc. Only that we've taken them to new highs (or lows), with the waistlines to show it.

Shrimp pancakes? To be honest, that doesn't sound half-bad. How how about bulgogi, potato & kimchi breakfast burritos? Oh, who am I kidding. I'm in a place where my tradition-bound co-workers look at me with horror when I tell them I had ramen for breakfast. ("But . . . lamyeon is for lunchee," they practically plead with me.)

Meanwhile, to our British friend who is aghast at the idea of heavy, oily, sugary, fried dough, I can only say . . . wait, what was I saying? I lost my train of thought, dreaming about Winchell's apple fritters and Lamar's chocolate glazed. Mmmm.

Maybe it's a good thing I'm on this side of the Pacific.

Unknown said...

Okay, I'll add a Canadian perspective to this. What Seoul and Korea needs is a few Tim Horton's franchises; better coffee, real cream, muffins that don't taste like cardboard and sandwiches made as you watch. And yes they have bagels too.

As for changing Korean breakfast habits, don't even try. Adapt to local conditions and things will be much easier and profitable. Besides, Mickey Dee's is the only place I know that can fuck up eggs. I wouldn't take my dog there.

That said, I did notice that the Dunkin' Donuts in Itaewon was open at 7am. Probably a case of micro-localization as the managers realize the local barbarian population will actually buy coffee at that time of day. Unlike the Starbucks in Kangnam I walked into one time at 7am. The barrista just about shat herself but managed to pour me a coffee and then locked the door after I walked out. Guess the suits in that hood don't drink latte at that time.

WeikuBoy said...

Up late, I just read Zen Kimchi's guest report of Doughnut Plant in Seoul. Wowee. That's just awesome. Homer Simpson Heaven.

Unrelated note: I feel so sorry for Stephannie White. But has she called her congressman /woman? The Koreans think English teachers are all losers. It would never occur to them that a teacher here now will ever amount to anything, much less go on to become president. (Cut to file photo of Obama as a boy in Indonesian madrasa.) Their society lacks such mobility; so they don't care what we say. They would however respect someone with power now, especially someone in Congress, with the KORUS FTA sort of still pending. Just a thought.

Anonymous said...

My experience with Dunkin' Donuts in Nowon. I'd go there Friday after work. I'd have a coffee and two donuts. At some point they stopped stocking donuts after 8 pm (the place was open until 11 pm). I'd go in there, it would be packed, but there wasn't a solitary donut to be found on the shelves.

Once or twice is an aberration but this went on for a couple months. I could understand if the place was dead but Friday night? In downtown Nowon? When it was always hard to get a table? No donuts?

You'd think someone would notice the place's night time donut sales had dropped. Or the guy running the outlet would reason "hmmm we're selling all these beverages... you know maybe if we had donuts we could up sell?"

I ended up routing around K-planning. Friday afternoon, I would buy my donuts at another DD's, throw them in my backpack, and then hit the Nowon DD after work and just take out my pre-bought donuts.

Sean said...

dunkin donut's coffee stinks. I would rather go to coobucks which stinks less, but still stinks, than go to dunkin.

Re: Tim Horton's - crap. I'm Canadian and I'd also avoid Tim's, it's overrated by overly nationalistic Canadians with no sense of good coffee or good taste.

Re: coffeeshops and not opening early. In Seoul it's hit and miss, but I think about 50% appear to be open around 7am. I have yet to find a coffeeshop open earlier than that which doens't make sense to me, but hey whatever works in Korea.

On the campus where I work we have 4 coffee shops. 2 open at 10am. Classes start at 9am. When I asked why they didn't open before 9 (this shop was next to the building I teach in) I was told it was too early for the owner to come to work. Go figure.

Douglas said...

EFL Geek,

For that traitorous insult to a Canadian institution you may consider your coffee privileges in 6-507 withdrawn on Friday mornings. Back to Starbuck's with you!

Sean said...

Doug,
so I lose 1 weeks worth of coffee? Ha!

See you next Friday for coffee.