Sunday, March 22, 2009

Obama didn't say what you thought he said about Korean education.


Cartoon from the Chosun Ilbo, March 12th in which two Korean kids are telling the two Obama children to not believe what their father said about Korean education.

I've been getting quite a few hits from people looking for information about President Obama's remarks on Korean education, so I thought I'd try and write it up more fully than trying to blog between classes last week allowed. President Obama didn't "laud" Korea's education of children. He has no plans to put a cram school on every corner and a "discipline stick" in every teacher's hand. The high monetary and social costs of private education aren't coming your way. Your kids won't be in class until 11 pm each night, and they won't be in school six days a week 27 months out of the year. Actually, rather than straining myself to make a bigger introduction, why not just reprint what he did say. Here are his two mentions of Korea, excerpted from the transcript of the speech to the Hispanic Chamber of Congress available from the New York Times:
Now, even as we foster innovation in where our children are learning, let's also foster innovation in when our children are learning. We can no longer afford an academic calendar designed for when America was a nation of farmers who needed their children at home plowing the land at the end of each day. That calendar may have once made sense, but today it puts us at a competitive disadvantage. Our children -- listen to this -- our children spend over a month less in school than children in South Korea -- every year. That's no way to prepare them for a 21st century economy. That's why I'm calling for us not only to expand effective after-school programs, but to rethink the school day to incorporate more time -– whether during the summer or through expanded-day programs for children who need it. (Applause.)

Now, I know longer school days and school years are not wildly popular ideas. (Laughter.) Not with Malia and Sasha -- (laughter) -- not in my family, and probably not in yours. But the challenges of a new century demand more time in the classroom. If they can do that in South Korea, we can do it right here in the United States of America.

The local media in South Korea focused on these two mentions, twice in seven sentences, with headlines like "Obama Lauds Korea's Education of Children" and "Obama Cites Korea for Educational Excellence." American outlets, on the other hand, looked at the bigger picture. "Obama backs teacher merit pay, charter schools," writes the AP. What overseas readers will need to understand is what happened in the Korean media here isn't that uncommon; fixating on the Korean side of the story at the expense of the bigger picture, rubbing themselves at getting attention in the "international" section for something other than Kim Jong-il or violent protests.

The second mention doesn't really look like a compliment at all, but more like somebody roughly saying "some place you don't know or care about is doing this, so of course we can, too!" Not to say Barack Obama doesn't care about South Korea---hell, the man knows a little Korean (not her)---but the first example reads more like a generic one-off comment than a thoughtful, exhaustive assessment of the Korean public school system.

Korea does have a lot to teach the US about schooling, most importantly its attitude toward education, which in America's case is embarrassing. But just be careful not to read too much into Obama's comments. Choi Yong-hearn, the Korea Times columnist ridiculed on this site a few times for his obsession with the Liancourt Rocks, Sea of Japan, and bad poetry, has done a bit of that recently.
The Korean school system has all kinds of problems. Many Korean people are ashamed of their schools. Many students feel that their schools are ``hell'' even today.

However, President Obama admires South Korea's schools and their products, educated manpower. He praised the Korean students who are competitive among students in advanced nations.

Korean students' performance is known to be superb, especially in the fields of mathematics and science. American teachers are amazed at Korean students' math and science scores. Obama's recent statement is just a reflection of the American people's admiration of Korean schools.

Amazing amplification of his comments there. And Choi, like the Chosun Ilbo cartoon atop this post and the original Korea Times piece that seemed to have spawned this whole distortion among people who haven't read Obama's full remarks, has pointed out some of the flaws of the Korean education system, mistakenly thinking Obama has endorsed it.

It's beyond the scope of this blog to give a full write-up on Korean education; I'll leave that to the many textbooks and articles already written by those paid to do it. I will just address the part about Koreans spending a month longer in school than their American counterparts. I think people are a little afraid of hearing this because the idea of a three-month long summer vacation is as American as apple pie. But just looking at Korea we can see it's practical, doable, and probably a good idea.

Students here go to school 220 days out of the year, compared to 180 in the US. Their school day is relatively the same length, though high school students are sometimes in school from dawn to late at night, sometimes even sleeping in dormitories. There is a half-day on Saturday twice a month, which is comprised in part of a "club activity": select activities include quilting, film, English club, and TOEFL prep. Students lives revolve around tests, and when these tests are finished they have down time. In December, after the final tests wrap-up the students have two or three weeks of little more than movies, cleaning, and most importantly, winter festival preparation.

As President Obama said, year-round school sounds scary to students and parents, but following Korea's example we can see it's not that bad at all. Students have roughly two months off in the winter and about five weeks off in the summer. To make up for those Saturdays, American schools might have to shave off a week or two here and there, though having a month-and-a-half off in the summer and a month off for Christm, er, "winter holiday" maybe isn't such a bad idea. And, well, considering how poorly American students are peforming, and how complacent we've become, I don't think we're really in a position to whine about taking away vacation.

In spite of the flaws of Korean education, which the Korean media likes to point out thinking its clever, we have a lot we can learn from South Korea, most importantly its passion for education. We can bicker about how efficient all this extra schooling actually is, but the attitude people have to school and schoolwork makes me embarrassed for my own education culture. I long for the day when Americans recognize that their position as a global power isn't guaranteed, and is contingent on learning how the world works and how they can succeed in it. And in the short-term I long for the day when Korean columnists knock off this crap about Obama and Korean education.

6 comments:

Michael Foster said...

I hate to give such a simple response, but I'm tired and it's Sunday evening. Brian: you're wrong. The passion for education in Korea is hardly laudable--it's part of the obsessive competition in this country, and it is extremely counterproductive. As are the long hours, the "respect" for teachers, the cram schools, the endless exams, and many other woes in the Korean system.

America's system is imperfect, but it is good; if you want to find a near-perfect educational system to learn from, go to Scandinavia, where any 10 year old speaks better English than many professors of English in Korea.

Tracey said...

I don't know that longer school years are the answer. Private schools in American usually go about 160 days or so and have fewer classes a day than public high schools and they are doing just fine. I think it is a viewpoint/attitude that the entire nation has regarding education. I ran into a girl who worked at walmart buying the movie "Twilight" and I told her to read the book. She refused. She told me she is in a remedial reading program at her high school and after she is done with that program she is never reading another book as long as she lives.......that to me spoke more volumes about our education system in America than any talk about numbers of days/hours spent in the classroom. In addition, I agree, education in Korea is about competition, not about education. We often speak about American education being bad and it definitely needs some help. But if you go into a school that is well funded and well staffed....you will see how good our education really is. The problem is that we are not consistent in the funding and staffing of schools and right now NCLB is killing education in America, what hope we might have had 8 years ago has been killed off by NCLB and the best thing Obama can do at this moment is kill NCLB.

Anonymous said...

'But if you go into a school that is well funded and well staffed....you will see how good our education really is. The problem is that we are not consistent in the funding and staffing of schools and right now NCLB is killing education in America, what hope we might have had 8 years ago has been killed off by NCLB and the best thing Obama can do at this moment is kill NCLB."

NCLB has done some good. Accountability has forced schools to pay attention to every child. The devil in the details.

First, NCLB requires all students who have been in the US for twelve months or longer to pass all exams, including reading. Beginning level students are allowed to have science, social studies, and math tests read aloud to them, but not reading. Research demonstrates that it takes 5-7 years for LEP children to acquire grade-level academic language and reading skills. An increasing number of our LEP students come from impoverished areas and did not receive regular schooling.

Second, the minimum passing percentage increases every year until 2013, when 100% of US students are required to be on grade level. This will never happen because a) children learn at different rates; and b)some children are unable to function in a school setting because of severe behavioral and emotional problems; and c) some parents exercise their legal right to refuse testing and services for SPED or ESOL. For example, last year there was a girl whom teachers suspected might be MR (mentally retarded). She could not understand even the simplest tasks in math, reading, or any other subject. Her parents refuse to let her be tested. If she fails the standardized tests required under NCLB, our school is held accountable. I support a guardian's legal right to refuse services, but the test scores of students who have declined services should not be counted. It's not only the loss of instructional support from qualified staff but also the loss of accomodations that facilitate learning.

Another difference between Korea and the US is that most Korean students live in stable homes with at least one working adult who keeps the child properly fed, clothed, and housed. An increasing number of American children are born in homes where there is substance abuse, in neighborhoods where there are few positive adult role models. These children cannot function in a school setting, and school districts devote a large share of staff and financial resources in coping with these children.

Chris in South Korea said...

Until the day Koreans feel recognized by the media world for reasons other than these, there will be grandstanding in the Korean media. Imagine being some little country that barely gets its share of airtime in the world news, and how you'll jump all over that whenever [your country's name here] appears on CNN.

Perhaps the Korean ATTITUDE towards education (e.g. it's important, worth spending money on, parents expect results) is better than the American attitude - but the Korean practices have a long way to go. I'm not convinced any one country has developed a model system that can be adapated by other countries in the world, although I am a fan of the Montessori system.

From everything I've heard and seen about the American public school system, it might actually be better to hit the reset button on the whole thing...

This Is Me Posting said...

America's education woes can be blamed 100% on Republicans.

When they equated "education" with the "academic Liberal elite" and turned academia into a bad word, your country was fucked.

I have never seen a group of people take more pride in being uneducated than American Republicans.

Mightie Mike's Mom said...

there may be a longer school year, but in the US, there's only 10 days a year that can be missed without endangering one's grades/ability to go to the next level. In Korea, this is 70 days. And many students do use these days due mostly to exhaustion. This from the mouths of my graduate students/PS Korean English teachers who were back in college for recertification courses. End game, the US student on average DOES spend more time in class room when you take into account those "sick" days.