Sunday, June 1, 2008

Moms don't like American beef either.



Moms pushing strollers were part of a massive protest in Seoul on Thursday after the government announced it would go ahead with American beef imports. Because obviously mothers are worried about the safety of their children. Which is why 12% of Korean drivers with children use carseats. Yes, Koreans actually fought against a car-seat requirement in 2006, and had the law repealed one day after it went into effect. But, according to one official at the transportation department, the logic of dropping the law was sound:
“The revision is also contrary to the government’s policy to increase the birthrate since it would be difficult for a family with more than two children to use car seats for all of the kids in terms of space and cost."

Yeah oiafuweofuosij3ue8wej. After everything that's gone on this past month, I shouldn't have even looked at that article, because I just can't handle anymore Sparkling. I just . . . I . . . why? *sigh* This is a difficult place sometimes. Anyway, that original Joongang Ilbo article up top also reports that truckers will refuse to transport shipments of American beef across the country.
The Korea Cargo Transport Workers Union made the announcement yesterday that its members will boycott such shipment orders [of American beef].

In other news, as first picked up by Korea Beat, the cops are letting protestors decorate police riot gear with bumper stickers. To be fair, it isn't June yet.

And just so we're up to speed, there's a famine in several provinces in North Korea, and Korean snipers at the Chinese border are shooting refugess. But it's important to remember the real enemy, namely the Americans who can't find Korea on a map who are trying to kill you with their leftover beef. The beef with Mad Cow Disease as reported on a show that since admitted it lied and misrepresented the dangers of American beef. Lied about a disease which consumers have an extreeeeeeeeemly remote chance of contracting anyway.* A disease that is 1/2300th less likely to kill you than a lightening strike. The beef that in all likelihood is safer than Korean beef. I can't think of any better way to carry yourselves in the 21st century. Oooooh, but look at us, with the Yeosu Expo! Oooooh, and the Universiade! In the "Culture Hub City of Asia!" And Hallyuwood and all the masses of brown people who watch your dramas and marry your villagers. Now you've made it~! Fucktards.



Recent cartoons from the Korea Teachers' Union website.

* The forums have been throwing out the 1 in 10 billion figure, which has appeared in a number of articles and on a number of sites, including this commonly-cited one and CNN.com back in 2004. I'm wary of quoting that figure, though, because there are too many caveats that a our more stubborn neighbors *cough* would latch on to in order to discredit the information totally, provided that they even acknowledge "information" at all. The CDC site actually says:
A rough estimate of this risk for the UK in the recent past, for example, was about 1 case per 10 billion servings. Among many uncertainties affecting such risk determinations are 1) the incubation period between exposure to the infective agent and onset of illness, 2) the appropriate interpretation and public health significance of the prevalence estimates of asymptomatic human vCJD infections, 3) the sensitivities of each country’s surveillance for BSE and vCJD, 4) the compliance with and effectiveness of public health measures instituted in each country to prevent BSE contamination of human food, and 5) details about cattle products from one country distributed and consumed elsewhere.

Regardless, the odds of contracting the disease are very small. As I and pretty much every other foreigner in this country have said, while there are perfectly acceptable reasons for protesting the FTA and for even protesting the import of American beef, this Mad Cow business is ridiculous beyond words. I'll admit I'm discouraged to see otherwise sane and reasonable people bewitched by this fervor. What's really unsettling is not the anti-American stuff that creeps in now and again, or the uncritical groupthink toward this particular issue. What's really unsettling is how quickly people around here tend to angrily swarm around causes, how ugly and how blatant their ulterior motives are, and how little room for minority . . ., um, positions there is. Whether it's Mad Cow, or the two girls killed by a military vehicle in 2002, or foreign teachers with Korean women in 2005, or the World Cup disappointment of 2006, or all the Liancourt Rocks crap, or the base relocation business, or the FTA stuff the past few years. Because what's more remarkable than those causes themselves, at least to me, is the wholehearted disregard of both fact and reason in the quest to support positions that seem to preexist the events themselves. Ignoring international media (and thus creating stories by omission), ignoring video evidence (or manipulating it to your liking), ignoring the scientific community (and promoting lies that most would consider incredible and unbelievable) . . . Perhaps I'm exaggerating and I'm overanalyzing things as bloggers are wont to do. But while I do admit to really loving being here 98% of the time, in the back of my mind I know it could be only a matter of time before people's ugliness turns our way again, and with potentially disastrous results. You know, I just mentioned fervent, sometimes violent, protests against the US military, the US government, foreign teachers, Japan, the Japanese government, FIFA, and Switzerland . . . anybody else see a disturbing trend? Then again, Koreans sure do love them some protesting.

4 comments:

Lee said...

Reasonable Koreans will admit that the odds of mad cow disease infection is astronomically low. But they'll raise other objections. Someone pointed out to me that the disease incubates within the human body for as long as 20-30 years before manitesting. This is true, but how many of older American have died recetnly due to dormant MDC from the 60's or 70's? We take better care of the cows compared to then.

One narrative that I heard (this might be an incomplete version) goes that Japan successfully blocked US beef import after finding a defective shipment not unlike the ones found in Korea (harmless bone fragments). The Americans obliged to Japan's superpower status but Korea is "weaker" so they can still have their way. In truth, Japan temporarily stopped US beef import after the violation, but they're still selling them over there.

This issue might register more with American media if the trading partner was Iraq or Canada. But Korea is just "one of those Asian countries way over there" to most Americans. Still, if Koreans continue to be stubborn and not honor trade agreements approved by both nations, there figures to be a response. This is an election year after all.

Unknown said...

One of my 13 year-old students wanted to discuss Mad Cow - I use the term discuss lightly. He really just said "U.S. Beef" then pointed to his head and rotated his finger around to indicate crazy. After proclaiming a few times that U.S. beef was just fine, I dropped to his level and brought up the bird flu. Well, actually I told him Korean chicken was "dirty", using one of their favorite words. He is quite the trouble maker anyway and smiled devilishly all the while saying I was wrong, their chicken was not "dirty". I use the dirty chicken argument with taxi drivers as well.

Brian said...

Candee, you're in Suncheon, right? I think we're facebook friends. Anyway, thanks for the visit. I just try to avoid the issue all together anymore. Yeah, there's bird flu all over the place. Yeah, more of their peers are dying in accidents than from Mad Cow Disease. Yeah, the media is lying. We know this, we all know this. But those are hard points to convey with the language barrier, to say nothing of the cultural blocks in place. In the past week or so I've just stopped the conversation whenever that's come up. Because it's never a discussion it's always a defense, me defending myself from whatever bullshit they can conjure up.

Total Bastard said...

Okay.. I'm going to do something terrible and agree with Korean. If (and I emphasise the if) there is a small chance that BSE infected meat is being shipped then they should avoid the Beef. vCJD is not destroyed by cooking (unlike avian flu), and is 100% fatal if contracted.
Sure it kills you slowly, but it does kill. If there is a risk, and there is an easy way to prevent that risk it should be taken.
Having said that BSE contamination and FTA should never share the same page, they should be separated completely.