The problem arose when the ministry and the immigration office abruptly began demanding the VSS document in September without notifying any of the parties concerned including the Canadian Embassy, teachers and local hagwon. Before that, Canadian teachers only needed a check from local or provincial police in Canada, which teachers can request while in Korea.
“Korean consulates in Canada suggested that we require the VSS from English teachers or teacher candidates,” said Kim Tae-soo, a deputy director at the Korean Immigration Service. “The VSS is very detailed.”
Kim explained that they decided to require the document because it shows records of crimes or drug use. He said in Canada, educational institutions require the document for those who work with children. Kim said the immigration office discussed whether to request this document with the Canadian Embassy in advance but did not notify the embassy that it had started implementing the policy.
“It was only an addition to the background check we have already adopted so we didn’t inform the Canadian Embassy,” Kim said.
Another problem with the VSS is that it is issued by different provinces in Canada that sometimes use different forms. The Korean immigration office has refused to accept applications from some provinces, such as British Columbia, that do not clearly show Vulnerable Sector Screening in large letters.
The recruiting manager said police in different towns and provinces in Canada should not issue a VSS if the teacher is not working with a “vulnerable” group or outside of Canada.
As an additional Catch-22, Canadian authorities do not accept fingerprints taken outside of Canada in processing VSS requests.
And Korean authorities won’t accept a background check by the Royal Canadian Mounted Police, though it’s more extensive than a VSS check. The problem: the RCMP documents do not include the key letters VSS.
“The VSS is to be used in Canada. The Canadian Embassy recently stated that it is impossible to get a VSS from Korea or any country outside of Canada,” the recruiting manager said. “You must be in Canada to get it.”
This means that Canadian teachers currently in Korea need to fly back to Canada at a cost of thousands of dollars.
“Many people are simply giving up. They will go someplace else like Taiwan or Thailand,” the Canadian teacher said.
Canadian teachers recognize the need for background checks but they said they cannot understand the lack of communication between the Korean immigration office and the Canadian Embassy. They say the immigration office did not try to inform the teachers.
“Background checks are a good idea,” the recruiting manager said. “But when they implemented the change they didn’t inform the Embassy. Not everything on the Web site of the Korea immigration office is up to date,” he said.
Monday, November 10, 2008
More difficulties for Canadian English teachers in Korea.
A Joongang Ilbo article today looks at more paperwork Canadian applicants have to deal with before they can get an E-2 teaching visa. Korean Immigration has, since September 1st, been requiring Candian applicants to submit a Vulnerable Sector Screening test as part of the visas application process. Go and read the whole thing, but I'll just include an excerpt. But wait, before you do, see if you can answer this "True or False" question: Korean Immigration implemented new visa requirments for Canadian English teachers without informing the Canadian Embassy. From the article:
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
8 comments:
The article (*shock*) is not 100% accurate. I just did this. Interestingly these checks are valid for the past 5 years and Korea is requiring even Canadian's who have lived here over a decade to get them done.
I called Toronto police where I last lived and they told me that they they cant do VSS unless the orgainzation registers with them and no Korean company qualifies to register with them. They said that Korean Immigration is well aware of this and has done nothing even though they keep telling them.
Every local police station though has different rules so then I called my home town and they did it all for me. No fingerprints were required. I got it stamped at the Canadian Embassy when it was sent back to me who knew very well what it was because of the steady stream of people that have been going in there. I then went to Gwangju Immigration and everything was A-ok.
Because I wasnt sure if they would accept it with out the finger prints I applied for the RCMP one too. The sent it back saying that they couldnt do it because I was out of country.
One co-worker of mine who couldnt get it done by her city's local police station did it through the RCMP but had it sent to her mother's house in Canada and then her mailed it to her here...the catch though is it can take several months to get it back and if your visa is expiring soon...
Fewer Americans because of the dollar, fewer Canadians because of this, looks like North America isn't in the ascendancy in hakwon terms these days.
Notwithstanding that this is some useless BS on the part of immigration, maybe we'll see a move away from American English being so sought after here?
Bring on the heavy Afrikaaner accents I say!
Koreans do not have a planning-in-advance gene.
If that sounds like an unfair criticism or a generalization, so be it. I stand by it.
I often wonder what my Dad would think of Korea. He's an old-school military man who believes in personal responsibility, defensive driving, following the rules, opening doors for strangers, letting others go first, being kind to everyone (regardless of social position), punctuality, and planning ahead.
I can't wait for the day when a person's QUALIFICATIONS outweigh which country they came from.
I've blogged several times about my frustrations over the inane and redundant paperwork here, mostly from the viewpoint that nobody seems to care about people like me who were "real" teachers back home. Some of the top TESL university programs* are found in Canada, seeing as English is considered a 2nd language in 2 provinces (Quebec and New Brunswick). We need to train ESL teachers for our own students, making places like Concordia and McGill the leaders in North American second language acquisition research and applied linguistics.
*Also unfortunately tops for TEFL certificate scams, a side-effect of the reputation*
Today is Remembrance Day. If anyone even DREAMS of asking me for another piece of paper to prove that I, someone who is personally anti-drug, have no prior drug convictions, I will explode.
p.s. I taught in 2 different schools in Canada for over 7 years and never had a VSS thing.
P.S. Remembrance Day reference was missing this link:
http://www.kvacanada.com/canadians_in_the_korean_war.htm
Qualifications? lol Out of frustration I said one day outloud at work how frustrated I was that I kept getting asked by people if I was a "real" teacher because I was one of the only ones at my place of work that actually IS a teacher (1 of 2 out of 15+). My co teachers who over heard got furious. Said that that was unfair. That they were "real teachers" too even though they dont have a degree. How dare I mention my education and training related to my employment?!?
Eh, okay, but that's a whole 'nother topic. Does wearing a Yankees cap make you a baseball player? Does reading from a Shakespeare anthology make you an actor? Does working 9 to 5 at a middle school make you a teacher? Wait . . .
I think it must be very frustrating being here as a "qualified" teacher, or "real" teacher, because I don't see much place for them in the schools. They probably have some better strategies for lesson planning, for classroom management, and for creating syllabi (sp?), but a lot of those factors get trumped by one's knowledge of how to survive in the Korean classroom. Moreover, whether you've got 22 years on the job or you're 22 years old, you're still just the "native speaker teacher," and after doing that for a number of years I can see how frustrating that can be.
I e-mailed the Canadian Embassy in Seoul yesterday. And (they are awesome!) I got this response:
*
The Embassy is aware of the problem and has been working with the MoJ to resolve the situation.
*
The Korean authorities are still requiring the submission of a VS check as a condition of E-2 visa issuance.
*
As per the Canadian Criminal Records Act, approved use of a VS check is very limited and restricted.
*
VS checks are not approved for use by foreign authorities. Korean authorities have been made aware of this fact.
*
Canada police authorities may not legally conduct a VS check for the purposes of teaching English in Korea.
*
The Korean MoJ has recently granted Canadian citizens a three month grace period to obtain their VS check.
*
Canadian citizens may lodge complaints to the MoJ at:
Border Control Team
Korean Immigration Service
Ministry of Justice
Government Complex Gwacheon
427-705, Republic of Korea
Fax: 82-2-500-9127
*
Canadian citizens may lodge complaints to their elected Member of National Assembly. You may find your elected Member of National Assembly at:
http://korea.na.go.kr/index.jsp
*
The Embassy continues to work towards a resolution of this problem
Hope it proves helpful.
Thank you.
Consular Services / Services Consulaires
Embassy of Canada, Seoul / Ambassade du Canada, Séoul
Post a Comment